What it means
New Jersey's model civil jury charge on negligent hiring states the rule most states share. An employer is liable if it knew or had reason to know of the particular unfitness, incompetence or dangerous attributes of the person, could reasonably have foreseen that hiring someone with those attributes created a risk of harm to others, and its failure to exercise due care in hiring, supervising or retaining that person was a proximate cause of the injury. Liability can also follow where a reasonable investigation would have disclosed the problem.
For youth programs
When an adult harms a child in a program, claims against the organization are often framed this way, and they can reach hosts as well as providers. For a host, the question becomes what it knew or could have learned about the adults a provider sent into its building, and what it did about it. For a provider, the question is the same about its own instructors. Each state sets its own elements and defenses.
What to look for
Evidence of a process, kept with dates: a screen run before work began, references, training, supervision rules such as a two-adult rule, and a record of what was done when a concern was raised. On a provider's record, each instructor has a row with screening status from the provider's screening partner, the abuse-prevention training date and the agreements on file, each with an as-of date. A current record is evidence of reasonable care; it does not decide liability.