The After-School Program I Closed as a Principal, and What It Taught Me About Systems
By Arielle Hammond, Ed.D. · Former school principal. Founder of Journey to STEAM and enrops. · Last updated October 11, 2026
After-school programs fail when quality depends on whoever happens to be in the room. I learned that in my first year as a principal, when I shut down the after-school program at my school. The adults running it were trying hard, with no curriculum, no structure and no support. A program lasts when a system carries the expertise, and principals and PTA leaders can ask to see that system before they say yes.
Who this is for: principals, assistant principals and PTA or PTO leaders who decide which after-school programs run in their building, and the providers who want to earn that yes.
What happened to the after-school program I closed?
Our after-school program was run by instructional aides who cared, who were trying, and who had nothing to work with. There was no curriculum and no structure. There was no support for what to do when 25 kids are at different levels, some of them struggling and some of them bored. It was chaos.
So I made the call. We shut it down. I knew exactly what that meant: the kids who needed it most had just lost access to learning experiences that could have changed their trajectory. These weren't kids who would go home to private tutors or expensive enrichment camps. School was it. And we couldn't deliver what they deserved.
Why do after-school programs fail when the adults care?
Let me not get it twisted: those aides cared about those kids. What they were missing was a system. Nobody gave them a curriculum, a structure for the afternoon, or support for teaching a mixed group. When a program depends on the adult in the room carrying all the expertise alone, it runs exactly as well as that adult can manage on that day. On the hard days, the kids feel it first. Quality can't depend on who happens to be in the room.
Here's the question that came out of it: what if those aides had been handed a system that carried the teaching expertise for them? That question is why I build systems instead of hoping for heroes. Heroes get sick, move away and have bad days, and a system shows up anyway. The stakes reach past one building. The Afterschool Alliance's 2025 America After 3PM survey counted 22.6 million kids whose parents want an after-school program and don't have one. When a school's program closes, those are the families who lose it.
What did closing that program teach me about running one?
I can't go back and change what happened in that school. But I can make sure other leaders never have to make that call. That call shapes how we run Journey to STEAM, the mobile STEAM after-school programs and camps we bring to school and community sites around Portland, Oregon and southwest Washington for kids ages 3 to 12. We create, field test, and refine our curriculum. We observe and coach. We seek feedback. We act on feedback.
Every one of those habits is a system doing work those aides were left to do alone. Class caps are a standard for us: 14 for older kids and 12 for younger kids, set after we watched an 18-kid cap fail in the room. Fewer than 10% of instructor applicants are hired. We end programs with a showcase where families see what their kids built, and our school partners renew at a 95% rate. None of that depends on one great adult having a great day. It depends on the plan being there when they walk in.
What should a principal look for in an after-school provider?
You can't sit in every room after the bell, and you shouldn't have to. You can ask for evidence that a system exists, and a provider who has one can show you. I covered the day-to-day side, like punctuality, communication and incident response, in what principals look for in an after-school vendor. Here's the quality side.
- A written plan for every session. Ask to see one week of curriculum. "Our instructors are great" means keep asking.
- A plan for mixed levels. Ask what the kid who finishes early does and what happens for the kid who's stuck. That exact gap helped close the program I told you about.
- Class caps in writing. A number set before enrollment opens, with a ratio you can hold the provider to.
- How instructors are chosen, trained and covered. Who coaches them, and who teaches when one is out. A written sub plan is a system.
- A registration parents can finish. The total in dollars, every date, pickup, who teaches and the refund rule, on one page. These are the seven checks a parent runs before paying, and your families run them whether the provider plans for them or not.
- Something families see at the end. A showcase, a take-home project or a recap gives families a reason to come back next term.
If you're the provider reading this, the registration piece is the fastest one to fix: create your first registration, free for businesses, and have a live link in under 5 minutes.
How can a PTA or school tell if an enrichment program is well run?
When the PTA or PTO does the approving, the flyers and the parent questions, that work lands on volunteers. The fastest test is the one parents already run. Can a family find the total in dollars, the dates, pickup, who teaches and the refund rule without emailing anyone? A clear registration page is what a planned program looks like from the outside. When every provider meets the same standard, your volunteers stop answering the same questions for every program, and your principal gets fewer surprise emails.
Free one-pager: Send This to Your School: the Parent-Friendly Registration Standard. One page a principal or PTA can hand every enrichment provider before approving a program, so every family gets the same clear answers.
Want the next one? Join the newsletter in the box below: one useful thing for kids programs, every other week.
Frequently asked questions
Why do after-school programs fail?
In my experience, they fail when quality depends on whoever happens to be in the room. The program I closed as a principal was run by caring adults with no curriculum, no structure and no support for a mixed group. Programs last when a written plan, trained instructors and clear standards carry the expertise.
What do principals look for in an after-school provider?
Proof that a system carries the program: a written plan for each session, a plan for mixed levels, class caps, trained and covered instructors, and a registration parents can finish. They also watch how a provider shows up, communicates and handles incidents. A provider who makes the school look good to its families earns the renewal.
How can a school tell if an enrichment program is well run?
Ask to see one week of curriculum, the class cap, how instructors are trained and covered, and the registration page. If a family can find the total in dollars, the dates, pickup and the refund rule without emailing anyone, that's a strong sign. The free Send This to Your School one-pager puts those checks on one page.
Sources
- America After 3PM 2025 National Fact Sheet (Lost Opportunity: Afterschool in Demand, But Out of Reach for Many), Afterschool Alliance, October 2025, link
If you lead a school or a PTA, send the Send This to Your School one-pager to every provider before your next approval round. If you run the program, send it to your principal yourself. That's how fewer school leaders ever have to make the call I made, and how more kids get a program built to hold up on the hard days.
Create your first registration. Free for businesses. Live in under 5 minutes. Or click through a sample registration first.
Want more free planning files? The enrops operator toolkit has eleven fill-in templates for camps, classes and after-school programs, all free.
Arielle Hammond, Ed.D. is the founder of enrops and Journey to STEAM and host of The Youth Enrichment Leader, presented by enrops.
Keep reading: all posts, guides, comparisons, pricing and The Youth Enrichment Leader podcast.
Your next registration could open today.
Create it, connect Stripe, share the link. Families register and pay in one place, and the money lands in your own Stripe account.
Free for businesses. Live in under 5 minutes.